Welcome!
This blog grows out of my conviction that every aspect of our lives is sacred and is to be nurtured and celebrated as a good gift of God. Most of the posts will be the sorts of things you would expect from a historian and worldview teacher, but some are likely to be a bit surprising. Since God created all things good, including all aspects of human life, everything is interesting and important from the perspective of a biblical worldview. Everything under the Sun and under Heaven is thus fair game here. I hope you find it interesting and enjoyable.
Monday, November 25, 2013
Misappropriating the Reformation 2 and 3: Sola Gratia and Sola Scriptura
The remaining articles in the series on Misappropriating the Reformation are up at the Colson Center. They cover sola gratia and sola scriptura.
Thursday, October 31, 2013
In honor of Reformation Day
On October 31, 1517, Martin Luther nailed the 95 Theses to the church door in Wittenberg, inadvertantly starting the Protestant Reformation. The following excerpt from my book The Reformation for Armchair Theologians, which I also published last year on this date, explains what all this was about:
This is where indulgences came in, particularly in connection with armed, fighting pilgrimages, or as we call them, Crusades. To try to drum up troops to free the Holy Land, the Pope had promised certain unspecified spiritual benefits to all who fought for the faith; the Church then needed to figure out exactly what these benefits were. The doctrines outlined above were elaborated to a large extent to answer this question. The Church eventually decided that going on a Crusade would remit the entire temporal penalty due to sins that had been confessed to a priest and absolved. But since not everyone could go on Crusade—women, the sick, the aged, etc.—and not everyone who wanted to go on Crusade could afford it, it was decided that if you paid the way for someone else to go on Crusade, you would receive the benefits of Crusading yourself. These benefits would be paid to you out of the Treasury of Merits, the collection of good works performed by Christ and the saints above and beyond what was necessary for their own salvation. The Pope was the custodian of this Treasury and could call a Crusade and authorize a withdrawal for the participants. (Not all the Crusades were to the Holy Land: the Reconquistà which drove the Muslims out of Spain actually began before the Crusades proper, and other Crusades were called against the Albigensians in France, pagans in the Baltic, the Hussites in Bohemia, and even the Pope's political rivals.) With the end of the Crusades, the practice of selling indulgences, as these crusading benefits were called, continued. Some were limited indulgences, which paid only for a specific period of time, say, 10 years of penance. Others were plenary indulgences, which paid the whole penalty. Leo's indulgence sale was the latter type.
The Indulgence
Controversy and the 95 Theses
First, following standard procedures, Luther sent a copy of the theses to his spiritual superior, who happened to be Archbishop Albrecht of Mainz. Like Queen Victoria, he was not amused. Second, some of Luther's students got hold of the theses, thought, "this is really hot stuff," and sent them off to a printer AFTER TRANSLATING THEM INTO GERMAN. Much to everyone's surprise, the 95 Theses became a runaway best seller, with translations following into most European languages. Despite the best efforts of professors since then, this was the only time in history that an academic exercise has generated such an incredible volume of sales. Luther thus unexpectedly found himself at the center of an international controversy over indulgences.
To understand the events leading to this break, we
must travel south to Rome, where Pope Leo X was building St. Peter’s Basilica.
Like any of us faced with financing new construction, Leo approached his
bankers for a loan. The Medici bank of Florence, which was owned by Leo’s
family, had been the papal bank for some time, though by Leo’s day it had been
replaced by the Fugger bank, centered in Augsburg, Germany. The Fugger bank had
been founded relatively recently, but it rose rapidly to become the largest
bank in the world due to the same silver boom in Germany that had led to the establishment
of the University of Wittenberg and the relative prosperity of the Luther
family. Jacob Fugger, the head of the bank, approved the loan, but this left
Leo with the problem of figuring out how to pay it back. Leo decided that the
best approach to handling that problem was to sell off some of the assets in
his treasury, specifically, the Treasury of Merits of which he was the
custodian. In other words, Leo decided to hold an indulgence sale.
So, what are indulgences? To understand that, we need
to know something about Roman Catholic conceptions of sin. According to
Catholic theology, every sin you commit results in both eternal and temporal
penalties. Eternal penalties affect your relationship with God; they are
spiritual and deal with your status in eternity, that is, whether you go to
Heaven or Hell. But since a sin against God is also a crime against your
neighbor, sins must also be punished in this life, hence the temporal
penalties, which are paid in time. When you confess your sins to a priest and
he absolves you, that absolution takes away the eternal penalty due to your
sins, but leaves the temporal untouched. He then assigns you a penance (a good
work) that you can perform that pays the temporal penalty. This may be saying
prayers, going on a pilgrimage, etc. These penalties could be pretty hefty; for
example, knights fighting at the battle of Hastings in 1066, in a campaign that
had been blessed by the Pope, were required to do 10 years of penance for every
person they killed in the battle. And this didn't even touch other battles the
knight fought in or any extra-curricular activities he might have indulged in.
If you die with your temporal debt unpaid, the remainder has to be paid in time
in the afterlife, so you go to Purgatory, a doctrine developed in the twelfth
century to deal with the problems associated with unpaid temporal penalties.
After your temporal penalty is completely paid in Purgatory, then you go to
Heaven.
So how do you avoid languishing in Purgatory for who
knows how long? There are a couple of possibilities. You could endow a
monastery or a church and get priests to say Mass or monks to pray for you. If
you pay the expenses, the credit for the time and the Masses goes to your
account. This may seem odd, but think of it like this: if you get a speeding
ticket, the town doesn't really care if you pay it or someone else does; it
just wants its money. The same logic applies here. As long as your temporal
debt is paid by someone, it counts. Going on pilgrimage is another good option.
Not only do you get credit for the time you spend on the road, but the shrine
you're visiting itself conveys a certain number of years of penance depending
on its importance.
This is where indulgences came in, particularly in connection with armed, fighting pilgrimages, or as we call them, Crusades. To try to drum up troops to free the Holy Land, the Pope had promised certain unspecified spiritual benefits to all who fought for the faith; the Church then needed to figure out exactly what these benefits were. The doctrines outlined above were elaborated to a large extent to answer this question. The Church eventually decided that going on a Crusade would remit the entire temporal penalty due to sins that had been confessed to a priest and absolved. But since not everyone could go on Crusade—women, the sick, the aged, etc.—and not everyone who wanted to go on Crusade could afford it, it was decided that if you paid the way for someone else to go on Crusade, you would receive the benefits of Crusading yourself. These benefits would be paid to you out of the Treasury of Merits, the collection of good works performed by Christ and the saints above and beyond what was necessary for their own salvation. The Pope was the custodian of this Treasury and could call a Crusade and authorize a withdrawal for the participants. (Not all the Crusades were to the Holy Land: the Reconquistà which drove the Muslims out of Spain actually began before the Crusades proper, and other Crusades were called against the Albigensians in France, pagans in the Baltic, the Hussites in Bohemia, and even the Pope's political rivals.) With the end of the Crusades, the practice of selling indulgences, as these crusading benefits were called, continued. Some were limited indulgences, which paid only for a specific period of time, say, 10 years of penance. Others were plenary indulgences, which paid the whole penalty. Leo's indulgence sale was the latter type.
Leo, of course, was not going to go out hawking
indulgences on the streets. The man who was reputed to have said, "God
gave us the papacy; let us enjoy it!" was not about to turn himself into a
salesman. Instead, he let it be known that for a fee, he would authorize other
ecclesiastical authorities to sell plenary indulgences themselves. One person
who bought into the scheme was Archbishop Albrecht of Mainz, in the Holy Roman
Empire. Albrecht wasn’t about to peddle indulgences on the corner any more than
the Pope was, so he sub-contracted the indulgences sale to the Dominicans, an
order of friars founded in the 13th century to supply the Church with preachers
and expert theologians. The Dominicans would sell the indulgences and take a
cut of the profits; the rest would go to Albrecht to recoup the money he had
paid Leo to hold the indulgence sale; Leo used Albrecht’s money to help pay
back the loan he had gotten from the Fugger bank to build St. Peter’s Basilica.
Unfortunately, the Dominicans were not above twisting
the theology of indulgences to make more sales. One of them, Johan Tetzel by name,
was a master of the hard sell and was generally the sort of person who gave
used car salesmen a bad name. He literally would tell his listeners that his
indulgences were so good that even if you had violated the Blessed Virgin Mary
herself, this would get you off the hook. He told people repentance wasn't
necessary for the indulgences to work and that it was a virtual ticket to
Heaven regardless of what you had done or would do. And when he couldn’t get
any more sales from that, he ratcheted things up a bit more. If you are not
worried about yourself, what about your dearly departed mother languishing
perhaps for thousands of years in Purgatory? Were you to spend but a few coins
on an indulgence, she would be released to go directly into Heaven. After going
on about this for a while, Tetzel would end with a little jingle: "As soon
as the coin in the coin box rings, another soul from Purgatory springs!"
(It rhymes in German, too.) There was no mention that indulgences applied only
to sins already committed, confessed to a priest and absolved, only to the
temporal penalties due to such sins, etc.
The Indulgence
Controversy and the 95 Theses
This indulgence sale upset many people. Among them
was Elector Frederick the Wise, the prince of Electoral Saxony and one of the
people who elected the Holy Roman Emperor. He opposed the indulgence sale for
two basic reasons. First, it meant that money his people were producing in
Saxony was being sent out of the country to Mainz and ultimately to Rome,
thereby hurting the prosperity of Electoral Saxony. In fact, Frederick
suspected the whole thing was a scam designed to enrich Italy at the expense of
Germany. Second, in addition to using his revenues from silver mining to build
the University of Wittenberg, he had also spent a great deal of it purchasing
relics; in fact, he had one of the largest relic collections ever assembled.
People went on pilgrimages to view these relics—further enriching Saxony's
coffers—and Frederick was afraid that the indulgence sale would hurt business.
So Frederick simply banned the Dominicans from his territories; Tetzel and
company were forbidden to set foot in Saxony, and thus the indulgence sale had
none of the negative consequences that Frederick feared.
This wasn't the end of the matter, however. The
University of Wittenberg had picked up a star theologian from the University of
Erfurt, an Augustinian monk by the name of Martin Luther. He had begun work as
a Bachelor lecturer at Wittenberg, then completed his doctorate in theology a
few years later. Luther was very proud of that doctorate, and always referred
to himself as Herr Dr. Luther. Luther had
new approach to theology based on the insights he gained from his Tower
Experience; he and his students had converted the rest of the theological
faculty at Wittenberg to his way of thinking. And like Frederick, Luther was
also upset about the indulgence sale, though more for theological reasons, and
thus he decided to back up his prince by doing what theologians did in the
sixteenth century: he challenged the Dominicans to a debate. Debates were the
standard academic exercise of the period, more or less like a combination of
term papers and exams today. The protocol involved first writing a list of
propositions, or theses, in Latin (the language of academia), which the debater
was willing to defend against either specified individuals or all comers. He
then posted the theses along with information on the time and place of the
debate on the University bulletin board. In theological debates, the theses
also had to be sent to the person's spiritual superior to be checked for
heresy. Luther wrote a series of theses against the abuses of this indulgence
sale—ninety-five of them, to be exact—and posted them on the University
bulletin board, the church door at Wittenberg. This has often been portrayed as
a great act of defiance, as Luther boldly challenging the corruption of the
Church. Actually, it was more like an act of conformity. All Luther was doing
was following standard procedures for debate in an attempt to defend what he
thought was good church doctrine against the abuses of the Dominicans. Although
the debate never took place (remember, the Dominicans couldn't enter Saxony),
two things came together to make the 95 Theses an enormously controversial
event.
First, following standard procedures, Luther sent a copy of the theses to his spiritual superior, who happened to be Archbishop Albrecht of Mainz. Like Queen Victoria, he was not amused. Second, some of Luther's students got hold of the theses, thought, "this is really hot stuff," and sent them off to a printer AFTER TRANSLATING THEM INTO GERMAN. Much to everyone's surprise, the 95 Theses became a runaway best seller, with translations following into most European languages. Despite the best efforts of professors since then, this was the only time in history that an academic exercise has generated such an incredible volume of sales. Luther thus unexpectedly found himself at the center of an international controversy over indulgences.
Monday, October 28, 2013
Misappropriating the Reformation: Sola Fide
The first of three articles on the Reformation and American Evangelicalism is up at the Colson Center. This one deals with one of the three core "sola" statements of the Protestant Reformation: sola fide, that is, that we are saved by faith alone. But the question is, what does that really mean, and do American Evangelicals understand the historic and biblical meanings of that phrase? The article can be found here.
Tuesday, August 6, 2013
New Book on the Image of God now available
My latest book, entitled The Image of God, is now available in print and in e-book form. The easiest place to find it in print is probably on Amazon, though it is available at other online retailers. It can also be found as an e-book in all formats at Smashwords. You can also find it available for Kindle at Amazon.
The cover description reads:
The cover description reads:
The Image of God is the centerpiece of the Bible's teaching
about what it truly means to be human. In this book, Glenn Sunshine discusses
fourteen aspects of the Image of God, what it has meant in history, and its
implications for today. By exploring the story of the creation in Genesis,
Sunshine details what the Bible says about human purpose and abilities, the
effects of sin on humanity, the impact of redemption, and the restoration of
humanity's original calling in Christ. Questions offered at the end of each
chapter make The Image of God ideal for personal or group study.
Monday, August 5, 2013
The Abolition of Marriage
Monday, June 3, 2013
Christians who Changed their World: Fei Qihao
A new article at the Colson Center. Fei Qihao was a Chinese Christian who survived the Boxer Rebellion and later became a Christian teacher and government official in China.
Sunday, May 19, 2013
Christianity in China
At the end of March, I
had the opportunity to spend 8 days in China
with the America China Civic Exchange, a Christian-based organization whose
purpose is to set up contacts, exchanges, and cooperative ventures between
individuals and organizations in China
and America .
I was there as an observer, to do networking, and to help lay the groundwork to
assist the Chinese in developing indigenous worldview training programs in the
churches.
The experience itself was remarkable. We flew into Beijing and flew immediately from there to Shenzhen; we then went to Guangzhou, then to Wenzhou, then to Hanzhou, then back to Beijing, then to Tianjin, then to Beijing airport for the flight home. We didn’t spend more than two nights in any one place. It was intense, and the meetings were incredibly diverse. We were involved with negotiation and/or planning for the first China/US joint television series, for developing hospice care and special education programs, for a university press to publish translations of books written from a Christian perspective for an online leadership program offered by a US Christian university, …. We also worked on collaborations with the person responsible for developing an e-commerce system for all ofChina .
She’s the granddaughter of one of Mao’s generals (the one who got the army to
back Deng Xiaoping as Mao’s successor) and a Christian.
And we met with Christian leaders. These were truly remarkable people, and I was humbled to make their acquaintance. I will tell some of their stories in later newsletters and articles, but for now, I want to focus on what they told me that they wanted the American people to know about the house churches inChina . It wasn’t what I’d expected.
First, they all universally and independently insisted that the situation isn’t as bad as is reported. Yes, the persecutions are happening, and yes, they are as horrific as reported. But they are at best sporadic and isolated, and often led by local authorities rather than the central government. In fact, the pastors all told me that they have a great deal more freedom than they’ve ever had in the past, and that is what they wanted me to emphasize as I talked about the house churches. Yes, there are restrictions: they can’t have more than 100 people (officially) at any of their meetings. But things are more open for them than ever. And it looks like they’re getting more and more open.
Second, the government’s attitude toward Christianity is complex. In a nutshell, they know that they need to deal with the problem of corruption inChina
or China ’s
economy will collapse. They looked into Buddhism and Daoism but concluded that
neither has the ethical resources to deal with the problem—that’s their
assessment, not mine. Christianity, however, does. But this raises a problem
for them.
The Chinese government is by its nature totalitarian, that is, it believes it has to have all aspects of society under its control. They started the Three Self Churches as state-backed churches, but those aren’t the churches that are growing; the independent house churches are. So that’s one group they can’t really control, and that worries them.
Frankly, they have good reasons to worry. First, if you allow one sphere to operate outside of government control, it opens the door to other spheres. This is what produced Western civil society, with its intermediate institutions (education, labor, business, family, etc.) that mediate between the individual and the state. If you allow one, it creates opportunities for others, and the government loses control of many areas of society.
Second, Christianity has been a revolutionary force in Chinese history. The Taiping Rebellion (1850-1864) was a massive civil war led by Christians (or a Christian sect) that left twenty million people dead—some estimates put it as high as one hundred million. The government doesn’t want to see a repeat of that, which may be one reason why they crack down on churches whose leaders seem to be growing too popular personally.
So the Chinese government is in a bind. They want the ethical benefits (as well as the ecological stewardship) of Christianity, but at the same time they want to control the church. I think that right now, they are trying to give the churches just enough freedom to influence the ethical climate in the country, but not enough to get out of the government’s control. I don’t think it will work in the long run, and I expect that the restrictions on the churches will be increasingly ignored and eventually lifted.
The experience itself was remarkable. We flew into Beijing and flew immediately from there to Shenzhen; we then went to Guangzhou, then to Wenzhou, then to Hanzhou, then back to Beijing, then to Tianjin, then to Beijing airport for the flight home. We didn’t spend more than two nights in any one place. It was intense, and the meetings were incredibly diverse. We were involved with negotiation and/or planning for the first China/US joint television series, for developing hospice care and special education programs, for a university press to publish translations of books written from a Christian perspective for an online leadership program offered by a US Christian university, …. We also worked on collaborations with the person responsible for developing an e-commerce system for all of
And we met with Christian leaders. These were truly remarkable people, and I was humbled to make their acquaintance. I will tell some of their stories in later newsletters and articles, but for now, I want to focus on what they told me that they wanted the American people to know about the house churches in
First, they all universally and independently insisted that the situation isn’t as bad as is reported. Yes, the persecutions are happening, and yes, they are as horrific as reported. But they are at best sporadic and isolated, and often led by local authorities rather than the central government. In fact, the pastors all told me that they have a great deal more freedom than they’ve ever had in the past, and that is what they wanted me to emphasize as I talked about the house churches. Yes, there are restrictions: they can’t have more than 100 people (officially) at any of their meetings. But things are more open for them than ever. And it looks like they’re getting more and more open.
Second, the government’s attitude toward Christianity is complex. In a nutshell, they know that they need to deal with the problem of corruption in
The Chinese government is by its nature totalitarian, that is, it believes it has to have all aspects of society under its control. They started the Three Self Churches as state-backed churches, but those aren’t the churches that are growing; the independent house churches are. So that’s one group they can’t really control, and that worries them.
Frankly, they have good reasons to worry. First, if you allow one sphere to operate outside of government control, it opens the door to other spheres. This is what produced Western civil society, with its intermediate institutions (education, labor, business, family, etc.) that mediate between the individual and the state. If you allow one, it creates opportunities for others, and the government loses control of many areas of society.
Second, Christianity has been a revolutionary force in Chinese history. The Taiping Rebellion (1850-1864) was a massive civil war led by Christians (or a Christian sect) that left twenty million people dead—some estimates put it as high as one hundred million. The government doesn’t want to see a repeat of that, which may be one reason why they crack down on churches whose leaders seem to be growing too popular personally.
Third, as one Chinese
individual explained it to me, the government knows that if they don’t deal
with the problem of corruption, it will be the end of China ; they
also know that if they do deal with the corruption, it will be the end of the
Communist party. And that means the end of their power, which they are
unwilling to give up.
So the Chinese government is in a bind. They want the ethical benefits (as well as the ecological stewardship) of Christianity, but at the same time they want to control the church. I think that right now, they are trying to give the churches just enough freedom to influence the ethical climate in the country, but not enough to get out of the government’s control. I don’t think it will work in the long run, and I expect that the restrictions on the churches will be increasingly ignored and eventually lifted.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)